Director Eva Husson (centre), Swedish actress Evin Ahmad (left),Iranian actress Golshifteh Farahani (4th right), producer Didar Domehri (3rd right) pose with French Culture Minister Francoise Nyssen (4th right) at screening of "Girls of the Sun (Les Fille
A harrowing film about Kurdish women fighters taking on Islamic State jihadists sparked a furious row between critics at the Cannes film festival Sunday -- with some being accused of misogyny.
"Girls of the Sun", which follows a platoon of Yazidi women battling the extremists who had enslaved them and their children, was premiered at the same time as one person was killed and four others wounded in a knife attack in Paris claimed by IS.
The movie, with Iranian star Golshifteh Farahani as a lawyer who picks up an AK47 to lead the Sun Brigade of survivors, is set in Kurdistan in the days leading up to the November 13 Paris terror attacks, in which 130 people died.
The premiere followed a historic protest on the Cannes red carpet by Hollywood stars and female filmmakers demanding equal pay and an end to sexism.
But as the curtain came down, a shouting match erupted at a nearby screening for critics.
A small number who had booed the film were shouted down by others, who accused them of disrespecting the film's female director and cast.
"It's not about you, dude. Not your time to talk," one said.
The divide was equally stark in the first reviews published Sunday, with the French magazine Telerama calling the war film "naive and inconsequential", while others said it was a "disservice to a noble cause".
- 'Condescending' critics -
But IndieWire's David Ehrlich said it was impossible not to be moved by it and called it a "surefire Palme (d'Or) contender", referring to the festival's top prize.
He conceded that there "was a little too much paprika on the sandwich where none would have done nice, but (French director) Eva Husson is one hell of a filmmaker."
French producer Claudine Nougaret Depardon took to Twitter to condemn the "misogynous and condescending attitude to this beautiful and courageous film.
"Let's fight to demand the early retirement for these (male) critics," she added.
The Guardian's Peter Bradshaw also rallied to its defence, hailing it as a rousing "feminist war movie: impassioned, suspenseful, angry".
While admitting that some might find it naive and "unsophisticated.... for me it is heartfelt, forthright and muscular."
But several French critics excoriated Husson's handling of the story, arguing that some of the women characters were paper thin.
The Hollywood Reporter was also critical of its "narrative histrionics and a tear-jerking score worthy of a Walt Disney movie".
But it praised Husson for "shining a light on an important and terrifying story that made headlines a few years ago but has since been forgotten by many of us."
Overall, critic Jordan Mintzer called it "a meaty all-female war movie served with an extra slice of cheese."
Leave a Comment